Best Tackle Shop Near Sag Harbor
If you’re planning a fishing trip around Sag Harbor, NY—whether casting from the jetty, drifting the flats, or heading offshore—you’ll want to start with the right gear, expert tips, and reliable local knowledge. Just 15 minutes away, White Water Outfitters in Hampton Bays is the East End’s trusted fishing supply destination. Conveniently located right off Sunrise Highway, this full-service tackle shop is a favorite among recreational anglers, charter captains, and tournament crews prepping for anything from surfcasting stripers to offshore canyon tuna.
🧭 Why Start Your Sag Harbor Fishing Trip at White Water Outfitters?
- Proximity & Speed: Located off Route 27, it’s the fastest stop en route to Sag Harbor’s boat ramps and beach access points.
- Local Fishing Intel: Get real-time updates on tides, bite windows, and bait movement from anglers who fish these waters daily.
- Huge Gear Selection: Stocked and sorted by species and technique, so you’re in and out without wasting time.
- Expert Services On-Site: Get your reels spooled, rigs tied, or lures tweaked while you sip coffee from the café next door.
🛒 In-Stock Tackle & Gear – Built for Sag Harbor’s Diverse Waters
|
Category |
Always Available |
Why It Performs in Sag Harbor Waters |
|
Rods |
Surf rods, inshore setups, offshore sticks, saltwater fly, jig-and-pop, custom builds |
Perfect for stripers under the bridge, drifting fluke on Peconic Bay, or dropping jigs over offshore wrecks |
|
Reels |
Sealed spinning reels, high-capacity conventional, electric deep-drop reels, saltwater fly reels |
Withstand salt spray, humidity, and powerful runs from bluefish, sea bass, and tuna |
|
Lures |
Bucktails, pencil poppers, epoxy jigs, soft plastics, squid jigs, teasers |
Proven producers during bunker blitzes, sand eel runs, and squid hatches |
|
Terminal Tackle |
Rigs, fluorocarbon leaders, sinkers, crimps, swivels, safety clips |
Matched to local species like black sea bass, porgies, fluke, and tilefish |
🛠️ On-Site Services for Serious Anglers
White Water Outfitters is more than a store—it’s a hub for East End anglers who need fast, reliable support:
- Braid & Mono Spooling: Precision spooled for max casting distance and smooth drag performance.
- Custom Leaders & Wind-Ons: Built on demand for jigging, trolling, or chunking setups.
- Same-Day Rod Repairs: Tip-tops and guides fixed while you wait (when available).
- Lure Modifications: Swap hooks, add flash tape, or adjust weights to match current forage.
- Line Recycling Drop-Off: Eco-conscious disposal for used braid and mono.
🔍 What Sag Harbor Anglers Say
✅ “Always my first stop before launching. They’ve got everything—and they know what’s biting.”
✅ “Picked up a killer fluke rig and got the best intel on where they were hitting.”
✅ “Spooling was quick, staff was sharp, and they saved my trip with an emergency rod repair.”
Google Review Tip: With over 100+ 5-star reviews, White Water Outfitters is recognized as one of the best tackle shops near Sag Harbor and Hampton Bays.
📍 Store Location & Contact Info
White Water Outfitters
📍 288 E. Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays, NY 11946
🚗 Trailer-friendly parking available behind the shop
📞 631-594-3336 – Call for live bait availability, specialty items, or bulk orders
🛒 Shop Online – Free U.S. mainland shipping on orders over $99
📸 Follow on Instagram: @whitewateroutfitters for tide updates, gear drops, and customer catches
🚤 Ideal Fishing Spots Around Sag Harbor
Whether you're launching from Long Wharf or heading toward Shelter Island, these hotspots are all within reach:
- Noyack Bay – Great for fluke, porgies, and weakfish in summer months
- Mashomack Point – Target stripers on the outgoing tide
- The Rips off Montauk or Gardiners Bay – Perfect for offshore trolling or jig-and-pop setups
- Shelter Island Flats – Ideal fly-fishing destination for schoolie bass and blues
🔑 Key Takeaway
Before you hit the water in Sag Harbor, take a quick detour to White Water Outfitters—the East End’s most trusted tackle shop. From surf rods to offshore reels, local fishing reports to on-site custom rigging, this shop has everything you need to maximize success on the water.
📦 Gear up close. Fish smart. Land more.
